VIEW: Nuclear targets —Bennett Ramberg
dailytimes.com.pk
January 1, 2008

Dimona has produced all the plutonium that Israel reasonably needs, and the reactor — one of the world’s oldest — has suffered minor mishaps and evident deterioration, raising the spectre of more serious accidents. So, if Israel cannot guarantee the plant’s defence against attack, it should close it

Nuclear facilities as military targets? The drumbeat appears to be growing louder. Western leaders repeatedly declare that no option is off the table to stem Iran’s nuclear ambitions. And, in mid-November, London’s Sunday Times reported that Israel put defences around its Dimona nuclear reactor on “red alert” 30 times, as worries grew that Syria would avenge Israel’s September attack on a suspected nuclear site in Syria.

Israel’s fear reflects the region’s unique history. Since World War II, strikes to halt nuclear activities have taken place exclusively in the Middle East: Iraq was struck by Iran (1980), Israel (1981), and the United States (1991, 2003), while Iraq bombed Iran (1984-87) and Israel (1991). But raids never generated significant radiological consequences, because plants were under construction, contained inconsequential amounts of nuclear material, had radioactive elements removed prior to the attack, or because the attacker missed the mark.

A successful strike on Dimona, however, would be another matter. So, given the threat of radioactive releases, does the plant’s continued operation outweigh the risks?

Dimona is unique. It is the region’s largest nuclear plant and sole producer of atomic weapons materials. Since it went into operation in the mid-1960s, it has generated elements for an estimated 200 nuclear weapons. Israel’s first prime minister, David Ben Gurion, inaugurated the enterprise to compensate for Israel’s strategic vulnerability, a fledgling army, and the West’s unwillingness to enter into a formal alliance to defend the Jewish state.

Dimona is no Chernobyl. It generates only about 5 percent of that failed Soviet reactor’s power. Still, the plant — along with its spent nuclear fuel, extracted plutonium, and nuclear reprocessing waste — poses significant radiological hazards that a military strike could disperse into the environment.

Israeli officials tacitly acknowledge the risk. Authorities have distributed potassium iodide tablets to the nearby towns of Yerham, Dimona, and Aruar. Potassium iodide blocks thyroid absorption of radioactive iodine, an early risk in a nuclear release. But it would not obstruct serious health consequences from other radioactive elements. And, depending on weather and the nuclear discharge, the radioactive consequences may not remain localised.

Light contamination and hot spots could impact Israeli, Palestinian, and Jordanian urban centres some distance away. Beyond health effects, contamination could terrorise affected populations, prompting temporary flight and permanent relocation. Serious, long-term economic consequences would follow.

For decades, Israel dealt with this risk through effective air defences and disdain for its adversaries’ ability to strike Dimona. In May 1984, after I authored a book about the consequences of military attacks on nuclear facilities, an Israeli intelligence officer came to California to question me about the vulnerability of the reactor and a proposed nuclear power plant. The officer belittled the risk, arguing that no Arab air force had ever overcome Israeli air defences, and none ever would.

At that time, history provided odd support. Although Egyptian reconnaissance aircraft had flown near Dimona in 1965 and 1967 without incident, during the 1967 war, Israel shot down one of its own Mirage jet fighters when it strayed over the facility. In 1973, Dimona’s defenders downed a wayward Libyan civilian airliner heading for the reactor, killing 108 people.

But the 1991 Persian Gulf War upset whatever solace Israel could take from the past. Iraqi Scud missiles bombarded Tel Aviv, and one came close to hitting Dimona. Hezbollah’s bombardment of northern Israel in 2006 further demonstrated the country’s vulnerability to missile attack. And, while Israel’s Arrow ballistic missile defences, which now surround Dimona, may be superior to the Patriot system that failed in 1991, Syria’s more advanced Scuds and Iran’s Shahab-3 rocket present a more capable challenge than Saddam’s projectiles.

Dimona has produced all the plutonium that Israel reasonably needs, and the reactor — one of the world’s oldest — has suffered minor mishaps and evident deterioration, raising the spectre of more serious accidents. So, if Israel cannot guarantee the plant’s defence against attack, it should close it.

By doing so, Israel could also derive political benefits. It could claim that closure demonstrates its commitment to reducing regional nuclear tensions, while sending a message about the wisdom of building reactors in the world’s most volatile region.

Indeed, about a dozen Middle East and North African countries propose to build nuclear power plants. Given the historic targeting of atomic installations, planners should consider whether providing adversaries with radiological targets far larger than Dimona makes sense. Until the Middle East resolves its political differences, it may not. —DT-PS


Bennett Ramberg, served in the Bureau of Politico-Military Affairs in the George H W Bush Administration. He is the author of several books on international security

=================================================================================

Israel's secretive nuclear facility shows rare film of interior to entice new workers
iht.com
January 2, 2008

JERUSALEM: Israel's secretive nuclear facility is trying to recruit new workers with a rare glimpse of the interior of the reactor complex that shows "it's very pretty inside," a spokeswoman for the Israel Atomic Commission said Wednesday.

The film was shown at a job fair at Ben Gurion University, not far from where the reactor is located in the southern desert town of Dimona.

Nili Lifshitz, a spokeswoman for Israel's Atomic Commission, said this wasn't the first time film from the plant was publicly displayed, and no sensitive material was shown. "We showed footage to show the place is very pretty inside and that regular people work there," Lifshitz told The Associated Press.

"This year a lot of people are retiring at once and the demand for engineers and physics experts is very high," she said, "and so we decided to show the film to compete with the other companies."

Pictures extracted from the film of the facility published in Yediot Ahronot Wednesday show the nuclear compound lit up at night, a production line for equipment used in nuclear medicine and a radiation detector.

Israel is widely believed to be the only country in the Middle East to have nuclear weapons, though it maintains a policy of "ambiguity," insisting it will not be the first to introduce nuclear weapons into the region, without confirming or denying their existence.

Much of the evidence that it has nuclear weapons is based on details and pictures leaked in 1986 by Israeli nuclear technician Mordechai Vanunu, who worked at the Dimona reactor.

The details divulged by Vanunu and published in the Sunday Times of London led experts to conclude that Israel has the world's sixth-largest stockpile of nuclear weapons, including hundreds of warheads. Vanunu was later kidnapped by Mossad agents and brought back to Israel to stand trial.

Israel's doctrine of "ambiguity" is meant to deter potential enemies from attacking. Officially, the nuclear facility in Dimona and a smaller reactor in Soreq, nearer the center of the country, are for research.

=================================================================================

Pacific Law Center
Specializing in criminal defense and DUI laws in the state of California. Offers free private consultations in San Diego. pacificlawcenter.com

DUI Lawyers in San Diego | DUI Defense Attorney in San Diego | Drunk ...
Learn about driving under the influence or DUI / DWI, commonly called 'drunk driving' ... In California, DUI stands for Driving Under the Influence of ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/dui.html

San Diego Personal Injury Lawyers | Personal Injury Attorney in San ...
Learn about personal injury law. An attorney at our San Diego practice can help if you or a loved one has been injured through the negligence of another party.
pacificlawcenter.com/html/personal_injury.html

Criminal defense attorneys - San Diego - Bankruptcy attorneys - Pacific ...
Read about the criminal defense, DUI, bankruptcy, and personal injury lawyers in ... He has handled numerous felony and misdemeanors cases in State and Federal ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/lawyers.html

San Diego, La Jolla - Medical malpractice lawyers - Attorneys with ...
For a medical malpractice attorney in San Diego County, consider Pacific Law Center. ... Doctors, dentists and other medical specialists, including hospitals and ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/medical_mal.html

San Diego birth injury and cerebral palsy lawyers, Pacific Law Center
If your child suffered a birth injury, contact the lawyers at San Diego's Pacific Law Center. ... Birth injuries are not always manifested early in a child's life. ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/birth_injury.html

Phillips and Associates, San Diego, California - Breaking Legal News
Learn about the harmful side ... Yamaha Rhino ATV Accidents " Trucking Accidents " ... Your Rights If Arrested " Types of Criminal Cases " Criminal ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/news.html

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy - Attorney in San Diego, California - Pacific Law ...
Read about Chapter 13 bankruptcy, also known as consolidation or a wage earner plan. ... Please do not feel guilty or ashamed. ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/ch_13.html

San Diego Truck Accident Lawyers | Trucking Accident Attorney in San ...
Large truck accidents can cause catastrophic injuries to drivers, passengers, ... A safety study published by the National Transportation Safety Board concluded ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/trucking_accidents.html

Auto Insurance Information - Accident Lawyers in San Diego, California
If you have been in an auto accident, the lawyers at our San Diego office can help. ... Even minor soreness can be an indication of a more significant injury. ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/auto_insurance.html

San Diego Domestic Violence Lawyers | Spousal Abuse Attorney in San Diego
Learn about your rights under criminal law when arrested. ... Home. The Law Firm. Our Lawyers. Personal Injury " Auto Accidents " Auto Insurance Questions " ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/domestic_violence.html

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy - Attorney in San Diego, California - Pacific Law ...
Read about Chapter 7 bankruptcy, also known as liquidation or consumer bankruptcy. ... One of the primary purposes of bankruptcy is to discharge certain debts to give ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/ch_7.html

San Diego car accident lawyers - Pacific Law Center
If you have been injured in an auto accident, the lawyers at San Diego's Pacific ... Home. The Law Firm. Our Lawyers. Personal Injury " Auto Accidents " Auto ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/auto_accidents.html

Contact our San Diego personal injury attorneys at Pacific Law Center
Residents of San Diego County with wrongful death, DUI, or other legal cases can ... If you have questions about any of our practice areas, from DUI defense to ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/contact.html

ORTHO EVRA® Birth Control Patch - Experienced Lawyers Serving San Diego ...
The ORTHO EVRA® birth control patch lawyers at the San Diego offices of the Pacific Law Center can help you if you've suffered blood clot-related problems due to ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/ortho-evra.html

San Diego criminal attorneys - Pacific Law Center
Learn about your rights under criminal law when arrested. ... Pacific Law Center is one of San Diego's largest consumer law firms and many of ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/criminal_law.html

San Diego Vioxx Lawyers - Pacific Law Center - Attorneys at Law
Learn about the harmful side effects of Vioxx®. The lawyers at our San Diego ... To view this, you need to install the Flash Player 7. Please go to here and ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/vioxx.html

Retaining a Criminal Defense Lawyer at San Diego's Pacific Law Center
Why hire a criminal defense lawyer from our San Diego law firm? ... Criminal offenses are often very serious. You could be facing jail, prison, probation, ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/criminal_defense_lawyer.html

San Diego Product Liability Lawyers | Product Defect Attorney in San ...
If you have a product liability claim, the lawyers at our San Diego practice can ... Strict liability means that a consumer has the right to not be injured if he ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/product_liability.html

Consult with a Criminal Defense Lawyer in San Diego - Pacific Law Center
Schedule a free consultation with a criminal defense lawyer in San Diego, California. ... All inquiries are confidential, but you can use an assumed name for ...
pacificlawcenter.com/html/criminal_consultation.html